FHSA Over-Contribution: The 1% Tax and How to Fix It

Painting of a glass jar overflowing with golden light into a navy tray beside a brass desk lamp: fixing an FHSA over-contribution

A first home savings account (FHSA) has a yearly limit, and it is easy to go over it. You might top up at two banks, or move money over from an RRSP without checking your room. The good news is that CRA sets out clear ways to fix it. The cost of waiting is a monthly tax.

This guide explains what CRA counts as an excess, how the tax works and the routes to remove it. It is based on CRA’s FHSA pages, read on 16 November 2026. It is general information, not tax advice. For the basics of opening and using an FHSA, see our FHSA guide.

Quick answer

Short answer: According to CRA (as of 16 Nov 2026), you have an excess FHSA amount when your contributions plus RRSP-to-FHSA transfers in a year are more than your FHSA participation room. You generally pay a tax of 1% per month on the highest excess in each month until it is gone. You also file Form RC728 and its Schedule A. You can remove the excess with a designated withdrawal or a designated transfer to an RRSP or RRIF, or wait for new room on January 1.

What counts as an excess

CRA’s excess amounts page says you may have an excess if your contributions to all your FHSAs, plus transfers from your RRSPs, are more than your participation room for the year.

Two points catch people out:

  • Room is per person, not per account. Contributions to several FHSAs all count against the same room.
  • RRSP transfers count too. CRA’s FHSA page says “Transfers from your RRSPs to your FHSAs are not deductible.” But they still use up room, according to CRA’s participating and excess amounts pages.

Key figures (CRA, as of 16 Nov 2026)

  • Participation room in your first FHSA year: $8,000.
  • Lifetime limit used in CRA’s excess formula: $40,000.
  • Tax on an excess: generally 1% per month on the highest excess in that month.
  • Forms if you have an excess: RC728 (FHSA Return) and RC728-SCH-A (Schedule A, Excess FHSA Amounts).

A worked example from CRA

CRA’s participating page gives this example. Karla opened her FHSA on 14 November 2026, so her room for the year was $8,000. She contributed $8,000 on 15 November and transferred $5,000 from her RRSP on 2 December. Her total was $13,000, giving a $5,000 excess for December 2026. She owes the 1% monthly tax on the highest excess in December 2026 and must file RC728 and Schedule A.

CRA adds that an excess left at year end also affects your participation room for the following year.

How to remove an excess

CRA lists these ways to reduce or eliminate an excess:

RouteWhat happensTaxable income?
Designated withdrawalYou take the excess out of the FHSANot included in income
Designated transferDirect transfer of the excess to your RRSP or RRIFNot included; does not affect unused RRSP deduction room
Taxable withdrawalA regular withdrawal from the FHSATaxable
New room on January 1The new year’s room absorbs the excessTax runs until then
Ways to remove an excess (CRA)

CRA notes that a designated amount cannot be more than your excess at the time you designate it. You cannot designate anything if you have no excess. CRA’s participating page adds that a designated amount restores your remaining lifetime FHSA limit.

A practical fix-it checklist

If you think you over-contributed

1

Add up every FHSA contribution and RRSP transfer for the year, across all institutions.

2

Compare with your room for the year, as CRA explains on its participating page.

3

Work out the excess and the month it began. The tax is charged monthly.

4

Ask your FHSA issuer about a designated withdrawal or transfer. Do this soon, because each month counts.

5

File RC728 and Schedule A for the year of the excess.

6

Keep the paperwork in case CRA asks questions.

Tip

Before moving RRSP money in, check your room first. CRA treats contributions and RRSP transfers as one combined annual cap: together they cannot be more than your FHSA participation room for the year.

Warning

Do not assume waiting until January is free. CRA charges the 1% tax for each month the excess remains.

FAQ

Is there a grace amount for FHSA over-contributions?

CRA’s pages describe the 1% monthly tax applying to the highest excess in the month. They do not mention a grace amount.

Does a designated withdrawal count as income?

No. CRA says a designated withdrawal is not included in income for that year.

Can I move the excess to my RRSP?

Yes. CRA lists a designated transfer to an RRSP or RRIF, and says it does not affect your unused RRSP deduction room.

Last checked: 16 November 2026.

This is one of the guides on our first-time buyers path for the US and Canada.

Related: to stay under the limit next time, read FHSA contribution limit: participation room and carry-forward.